Responsive image
Article On the Issue of Patient-Consumer Protection Guarantees When Performing Pharmaceutical Activities
Authors ANDRII ZELINSKYІ
Name of magazine Legal journal «Law of Ukraine» (Ukrainian version)
Issue 10 / 2022
Pages 112 - 129
Annotation

The conducted research is due to the lack of an unambiguous definition of the concepts “pharmaceutical assistance”, “pharmaceutical service”, “pharmaceutical activity” in the doctrine. The purpose of the article is to develop a generalized scientific vision of the essence of pharmaceutical activity, to clarify its specifics and subject composition, guarantees for the exercise and protection of rights by the latter, to develop a rationale for the theoretical foundations for further reform of civil legislation regulating legal relations in the field of pharmaceutical activity. It was found that in doctrinal studies, depending on the field of their research, the concept of pharmaceutical activity can be used in different understandings. The scientific hypothesis underlying the article is the analysis of pharmaceutical activity only as an economic activity directly related to the circulation of medicinal products, the provision of pharmaceutical services and assistance. The correctness of the legislative approach, according to which the pharmaceutical service is a form of civil law circulation of pharmaceutical aid, has been confirmed. The content of pharmaceutical services is pharmaceutical assistance. The ambiguity in the understanding of a person who is a consumer of pharmaceutical services in the doctrinal literature has been established. The conducted analysis made it possible to conclude that the final recipient of pharmaceutical services and pharmaceutical activity is the patient, who at the same time has the status of a consumer. The correct name of such a person should be recognized as “patient-consumer”, which allows to distinguish him from the patient as a subject of medical legal relations. The extension of the status of consumers to patients is conditioned, among other things, by the attribution of pharmaceutical activity to entrepreneurial activity – trade, the purpose of which is to expand the volume of distribution of goods (medicines and medical products) and obtain maximum profit.The issue of specific guarantees for the protection of consumer rights in the field of pharmaceutical activity is being investigated. It was established that the most important criteria for appropriateness of services in pharmaceutical activity should be recognized as: compliance with high quality requirements of medicines and medical products; relevance of medicines and medical devices; proper informing of the consumer; availability of proper and accessible service of pharmaceutical activity; compliance with pharmaceutical ethics; application of the provisions of “Proper Pharmacy Practice”; pricing and state regulation of prices for some medicines and medical products. Peculiarities of protecting the rights of the patient-consumer in case of sale of medical products of inappropriate quality have been studied.

 

Keywords abuse of law; information relations; information with limited access; discretionary powers; subjective law
References

Bibliography

Journal articles

1. Bilous S, Yakovenko A, ‘Napriamy pidvyshchennia konkurentospromozhnosti posluh farmatsevtychnoho pidpryiemstva’ (2021) 25 Ekonomika ta suspilstvo https://doi. org/10.32782/2524-0072/2021-25-34 (in Ukrainian).

2. Hala L, Brovchenko A, ‘Doslidzhennia suchasnykh aspektiv diialnosti farmatsevtychnykh pratsivnykiv’ (2012) 2 Farmatsevtychnyi zhurnal 14–9 (in Ukrainian).

3. Hromovyk B, Pankevych O, ‘Istoriohenez samorehuliuvannia farmatsevtychnoi diialnosti na terenakh Ukrainy’ (2020) 3 Farmatsevtychnyi chasopys 60–9 (in Ukrainian).

4. Hromovyk B, Pankevych O, Bilushchak H, ‘Samorehuliuvannia farmatsevtychnoi diialnosti v Ukraini: opiniia provizoriv i farmatsevtiv’ [2020] 75 (5) Farmatsevtychnyi zhurnal 15–22 (in Ukrainian).

5. Hromovyk B, Unhurian L, ‘Naukove bachennia vzaiemozv’iazku lohistychnoho obsluhovuvannia patsiientiv z kontseptsiiamy farmatsevtychnoi dopomohy i nalezhnoi aptechnoi praktyky’ [2012] 4 (73) Zaporozhskyi medytsynskyi zhurnal 81–4 (in Ukrainian).

6. Kutuzova D, Stepurko T, Kovtoniuk P, ‘Patsiient, spozhyvach chy kliient? Yak nazyvaty tykh, khto po tsei bik likarni?’ (2015) 174 Naukovi zapysky NaUKAMA. Sotsiolohichni nauky 86–91 (in Ukrainian).

7. Marova S, Vovk S, ‘Medychna posluha yak tovar medychnoho rynku’ (2017) 4 Derzhavne upravlinnia: udoskonalennia ta rozvytok (in Ukrainian).

8. Morshchahina M, ‘Asortyment aptechnykh zakladiv yak predmet hospodarskopravovoi rehlamentatsii’ [2012] 1 (8) Visnyk Natsionalnoho universytetu “Iurydychna akademiia Ukrainy imeni Yaroslava Mudroho” 209–16 (in Ukrainian).

9. Myronyshyna O, ‘Problema tsinoutvorennia u farmatsevtychnomu sektori: svitovyi dosvid vykorystannia mekhanizmiv derzhavnoho rehuliuvannia’ (2008) 10 Nauka moloda 25–9 (in Ukrainian).

10. Pashkov V, ‘Osoblyvosti tsinovoi polityky derzhavy shchodo produktsii farmatsevtychnoho vyrobnytstva’ (2012) 3 Visnyk Natsionalnoi akademii pravovykh nauk Ukrainy 146–58 (in Ukrainian).

11. Pasko I, ‘Sub’iekt medychnoi sfery: patsiient, kliient, spozhyvach medychnykh posluh’ (2017) 9 Ekonomika i suspilstvo 1–13 (in Ukrainian).

12. Posokhova K, Matvieieva O, ‘Vplyv indyvidualnykh osoblyvostei orhanizmu, patolohichnykh protsesiv, kombinovanoho zastosuvannia likarskykh zasobiv na yikh efektyvnist’ [2018] 4 (126) 2 Ukr. Med. Chasopys 14–8 (in Ukrainian).

13. Slyvka Ya, ‘Pokupets i zamovnyk: spilne i vidminne’ [2017] 4 (50) Visnyk Zhytomyrskoho derzhavnoho tekhnolohichnoho universytetu 166–70 (in Ukrainian).

14. Vasyliev V, ‘Zakonodavche zakriplennia poniattia “farmatsevtychna diialnist” yak peredumova pidvyshchennia efektyvnosti derzhavnoho upravlinnia u sferi obihu likarskykh zasobiv’ (2011) 4 Visnyk Kharkivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu vnutrishnikh sprav 14–20 (in Ukrainian).

 

Theses

15. Auhunas S, ‘Kompleksne naukovo-teoretychne obgruntuvannia zakonomirnostei rozvytku systemy medykamentoznoho zabezpechennia naselennia Ukrainy z noofarma tsevtychnykh ta emerdzhentnykh pozytsii’ (dys kand farmatsevt nauk, 2019) (in Ukrainian).

16. Karmanova V, ‘Social’nye determinanty potreblenija farmacevticheskih produktov’ (avtoref dis kand sociolog nauk, 2010) (in Russian).

17. Mytych S, ‘Zlochyny, shcho vchyniaiutsia u sferi vyhotovlennia ta obihu likarskykh zasobiv v Ukraini: kryminolohichna kharakterystyka, determinatsiia ta zapobihannia’ (avtoref dys kand yuryd nauk, 2019) (in Ukrainian).

18. Torb’iak B, ‘Otsiniuvannia pryvablyvosti ta prohnozuvannia rozvytku farmatsevtychnykh rynkiv v rehionakh Ukrainy’ (dys kand ekon nauk, 2019) (in Ukrainian).

19. Unhurian L, ‘Naukovo-praktychne obgruntuvannia kontseptsii farmatsevtychnoi dopomohy naselenniu na zasadakh lohistychnoho obsluhovuvannia’ (avtoref dys d-ra farm. nauk, 2015) (in Ukrainian).

 

Conference paper

 20. Chehrynets A, Babicheva H, Rohulia O, ‘Doslidzhennia prychyn vynyknennia konfliktiv u protsesi nadannia farmatsevtychnoi dopomohy’ v Menedzhment ta marketynh u skladi suchasnoi ekonomiky, nauky, osvity, praktyky: materialy VIII mizhnar. nauk.-prakt. dystants. konf. (NFaU 2020) 83-90 (in Ukrainian).

 

 Websites

21. ‘Derzhliksluzhba poiasnyla, yak ukraintsi mozhut pereviryty yakist likiv’ (accessed: 28.10.2022) (in Ukrainian).

 22. ‘Do vidoma spozhyvachiv likarskykh zasobiv’ (Derzhavna sluzhba Ukrainy z likarskykh zasobiv ta kontroliu za narkotykamy, 28.08.2020) (accessed: 28.10.2022) (in Ukrainian).

23. ‘Nalezhna farmatsevtychna dopomoha – zaporuka pokrashchennia hromadskoho zdorov’ia’ (Vseukrainska farmatsevtychna palata) (accessed: 28.10.2022) (in Ukrainian).

24. ‘Povernuty liky v apteky mozhna lyshe za naiavnosti dokumenta, shcho pidtverdzhuie yikh nenalezhnu yakist’ (Holovne upravlinnia Derzhprodspozhyvsluzhby v oblasti) (accessed: 28.10.2022) (in Ukrainian).

25. Klimov O, ‘Farmatsevtychna posluha – marker profesiinosti ta kvalifikovanosti farmatsevtychnoho pratsivnyka’ (№ 31, 19 serpnia 2019 r.) (accessed: 28.10.2022) (in Ukrainian).

26. Mnushko Z, Slobodianiuk M, ‘Farmatsevtychna diialnist’ (Farmatsevtychna entsyklopediia) (accessed: 28.10.2022) (in Ukrainian).

 27. Nemchenko A, Panfilova H, ‘Farmatsevtychna dopomoha’ (Farmatsevtychna entsyklopediia) (accessed: 28.10.2022) (in Ukrainian).

28. Pertsev I, Trokhymchuk V, ‘Patsiient’ (Farmatsevtychna entsyklopediia) (accessed: 28.10.2022) (in Ukrainian).

 

Electronic version Download